Our comprehensive analysis of 47 D2C brands reveals a stark reality: the average brand loses 12-18% of potential profit to hidden operational leakage. This isn't about marketing spend or customer acquisition—it's about what happens after the sale is made.
Executive Summary
Over the past 18 months, TrueLens has conducted deep-dive profitability analyses across 47 direct-to-consumer brands in India, spanning fashion, beauty, electronics, and home goods categories. Our findings challenge the conventional wisdom that growth is the primary driver of D2C success.
The data tells a different story: brands that focus obsessively on post-sale economics consistently outperform their growth-focused peers, not just in profitability, but in sustainable revenue growth as well.
Key Findings
1. The Invisible Margin Gap
On average, there's a 14.3% gap between what D2C brands think they're making on each order and what actually reaches their bank account. This “invisible margin gap” stems from untracked costs in logistics, returns processing, payment gateway fees, and operational inefficiencies.
The Math That Most Brands Miss
A ₹1,000 order with a “40% margin” often delivers only ₹257 to the bottom line after all costs are accounted for. Yet most brands still report—and make decisions based on—that 40% figure.
2. Inventory: The Silent Profit Killer
Inventory issues account for 31% of all profit leakage we've identified. This includes:
- Dead stock: On average, 18% of SKUs haven't moved in 90+ days
- Stock-outs: Popular items are unavailable 12% of the time
- Overproduction: Brands produce 23% more than they sell at full price
- Storage costs: Carrying costs are typically underestimated by 40%
3. The Return Reality
Returns in India's D2C sector average 18-25% for fashion brands. But the true cost of returns extends far beyond logistics:
- Processing and inspection: ₹45-80 per return
- Restocking and repackaging: ₹25-40 per unit
- Value degradation: 15-30% markdown on returned items
- Customer service time: Often untracked
4. Geographic Profit Variance
Profitability varies dramatically by pincode. Our analysis shows that 22% of pincodes served by the average D2C brand are actually unprofitable when all costs are considered. Yet brands continue to offer uniform pricing and shipping policies across all regions.
Recommendations
Based on our research, we recommend D2C brands take these immediate actions:
- Implement true SKU-level P&L tracking that includes all variable costs, not just COGS
- Create a dead stock liquidation protocol with clear triggers and channels
- Analyze geographic profitability and consider differential pricing or service levels
- Build return reduction into product development using return reason data
- Audit vendor contracts annually for hidden fees and overcharges
Ready to Find Your Hidden Profit?
Get a complimentary profit leakage assessment for your D2C brand.
Book Discovery Call →Methodology
This report is based on analysis of financial and operational data from 47 D2C brands between January 2023 and December 2024. Brands range from ₹3Cr to ₹150Cr in annual revenue. All data has been anonymized and aggregated to protect client confidentiality.
For the complete methodology and additional data tables, download the full PDF report.